Side by side comparison: ASICS Magic Speed 5 vs Puma Deviate Nitro 3

ASICS Magic Speed 5
ASICSMagic Speed 5

Speed Trainer

Product Judgment

8.2

Strong

released 2026

Price Judgment

~$170$210$192$157$140

Reasonable

Widely Available

Performance

Comfort: 7Energy Return: 8Stability: 7Durability: 6Fun to Ride: 9

Run Fitness

Daily: 6Long: 7Tempo: 9Race: 8Recovery: 5

Pros & Cons

Lightweight, agile feel
Responsive carbon plate
Excellent grip
Upper mesh durability concerns
Narrow fit limits comfort

Specs

Best for3:45-5:15 min/km
Drop7 mm
Stack35.3 mm heel / 26.6 mm forefoot
Weight201 g
Terrainroad
Widthmedium
Pronationneutral
Seasonall seasons
PlateCarbon

Judgment Summary

Light, responsive carbon-plated trainer ideal for tempo runs and fast training.

Puma Deviate Nitro 3
PumaDeviate Nitro 3

Speed Trainer

Product Judgment

8.2

Strong

released 2024

Price Judgment

~$120$196$180$147$131

Strong Buy

Phasing Out

Performance

Comfort: 8Energy Return: 9Stability: 6Durability: 7Fun to Ride: 8

Run Fitness

Daily: 8Long: 7Tempo: 9Race: 7Recovery: 6

Pros & Cons

Excellent energy return
Outstanding grip
Snug, race-ready fit
Narrow fit limits comfort
Limited stability
Moderate durability

Specs

Best for4:00–5:30 min/km
Drop10 mm
Stack39 mm heel / 29 mm forefoot
Weight268 g
Terrainroad
Widthmedium
Pronationneutral
Seasonall seasons
PlateCarbon

Judgment Summary

A strong, carbon-plated speed trainer with excellent energy return and a snug fit for fast training.

Where to Buy