Side by side comparison: Brooks Hyperion Max 4 vs Hoka Mach X 3

Product Judgment

8.1

Strong

released 2026

Price Judgment

~$200$201$185$151$134

Overpriced

Widely Available

Performance

Comfort: 8Energy Return: 8Stability: 8Durability: 7Fun to Ride: 7

Run Fitness

Daily: 7Long: 9Tempo: 8Race: 6Recovery: 5

Pros & Cons

Outstanding long-run comfort
Secure, premium upper
Stable platform
Heavier than competitors
Narrow fit
Limited breathability

Specs

Best for4:15–5:30 min/km
Drop6 mm
Stack45mm total stack height
Weight286 g
Terrainroad
Widthmedium
Pronationneutral
Seasonall seasons
PlateComposite

Judgment Summary

Premium super trainer with plush comfort, stable ride, and responsive forefoot for long runs.

Where to Buy

Hoka Mach X 3
HokaMach X 3

Speed Trainer

Product Judgment

8.2

Strong

released 2025

Price Judgment

~$190$203$186$152$135

Overpriced

Widely Available

Performance

Comfort: 8Energy Return: 9Stability: 7Durability: 8Fun to Ride: 8

Run Fitness

Daily: 7Long: 8Tempo: 9Race: 7Recovery: 6

Pros & Cons

Propulsive, energetic ride
Improved heel comfort
Versatile for workouts
Snug toebox limits comfort
Heavier than some rivals
Tongue can shift

Specs

Best for3:45–5:15 min/km
Drop5 mm
Stack44 mm heel / 39 mm forefoot
Weight288 g
Terrainroad
Widthmedium
Pronationneutral
Seasonall seasons
PlateComposite

Judgment Summary

A strong, propulsive speed trainer with improved comfort, best for tempo and long workouts.

Where to Buy