Side by side comparison: Hoka Cielo X1 3.0 vs New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5

Product Judgment

8.3

Strong

released 2026

Price Judgment

~$275$267$245$201$178

Unjustified

Widely Available

Performance

Comfort: 6Energy Return: 9Stability: 6Durability: 7Fun to Ride: 9

Run Fitness

Daily: 4Long: 7Tempo: 9Race: 9Recovery: 3

Pros & Cons

Extremely propulsive ride
Lightweight for stack height
Excellent forefoot bounce
Unstable heel for heel strikers
Restrictive fit
Demanding at slow paces

Specs

Best for3:00-4:30 min/km
Drop7 mm
Stack38 mm heel / 31 mm forefoot
Weight193-223 g
Terrainroad
Widthmedium
Pronationneutral
Seasonall seasons
PlateCarbon

Judgment Summary

Aggressive, propulsive super shoe excelling at fast efforts but less comfortable and stable for heel strikers.

Product Judgment

8.5

Strong

released 2025

Price Judgment

~$250$280$257$210$187

Reasonable

Widely Available

Performance

Comfort: 8Energy Return: 9Stability: 8Durability: 7Fun to Ride: 8

Run Fitness

Daily: 6Long: 9Tempo: 8Race: 9Recovery: 4

Pros & Cons

Stable for a super shoe
Comfortable over marathon distance
Strong propulsion
Not the lightest racer
Less explosive than top rivals
Limited daily durability

Specs

Best for3:15-4:45 min/km
Drop4 mm
Stack40 mm heel / 36 mm forefoot
Weight212 g
Terrainroad
Widthmedium
Pronationneutral
Seasonsummer
PlateCarbon

Judgment Summary

Balanced super shoe combining comfort, stability, and propulsion for marathon racing.

Where to Buy